TOXICity — Walkthrough (Prologue – Chapter 10)

This walkthrough covers every meaningful choice from the Prologue through Chapter 10, including the stat effects on Love (L), Friend (F), Desire (D), Trust (T) and Anxiety (A). Conditions that unlock a choice or change its outcome are noted in italics above the choice.

Choice

• “Keep quiet”
• “Agree with Laura.” F Laura +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “You have a reason to go home.” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)
• “I’m leaving soon.”

Choice

• “She was just checking in.”
• “She mentioned something about smoke.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

The chapter begins with: A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “No signal myself.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)
• “Let me try the landline.”

Choice

• “Not answering.”
• “Let me try Laura.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “Tell her you already tried that.” F Kallie -1 (Friend)
• “Let her do this.”

Choice

• “Leave her be.”
• “Ask.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “Be blunt.”
• “Try to lift her spirits.” A Kallie -1 (Anxiety)

The following morning, you will automatically get: A Kallie +1 (Anxiety) D Kallie +1 (Desire)

Choice

• “Reassure her.” A Kallie -1 (Anxiety)
• “Keep silent.”

Choice

• “Suggest Kallie take her.” T Kallie +1 (Trust)
• “Take her yourself.” F Laura +1 (Friend) D Laura +1 (Desire)

Choice

• “Turn away.”
• “Don’t mention it.” D Laura +1 (Desire)

Choice

• “Mention it.” A Laura +1 (Anxiety) T Laura +1 (Trust) A Kallie +1 (Anxiety) T Kallie +1 (Trust)
• “Don’t.” This decision will eventually net you the following: A Laura +1 (Anxiety) T Laura -1 (Trust) A Kallie +1 (Anxiety) T Kallie -1 (Trust)

Choice

• “Don’t mention it.”
• “Say something.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety) F Kallie +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “Don’t know.”
• “Eventually, yes.”

When talking with Laura at night, if you didn’t look away in the bathroom, you will get the following:

Choice

• “Highlight of my day.” F Laura +1 (Friend)
• “Didn’t really pay any attention to it.”

Choice

• “Not like you need it.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)
• “Keep quiet.”

Choice

• “Kallie.” F Kallie +1 (Friend) A Kallie -1 (Anxiety)
• “Laura.” F Laura +1 (Friend) A Laura -1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Sneak past.”
• “Good morning.” If Kallie’s Trust is 1 or greater: D Kallie +1 (Desire) — Else: A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Sounds good.”
• “Are you sure you want to see me again after this?”

Choice

• “Don’t mention it.”
• “Say something.” F Laura +1 (Friend) T Laura +1 (Trust)

At the end of the chapter, you will get: A Laura +1 (Anxiety) A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Or too tired to care.”
• “And you don’t?” F Laura +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “We’ll talk to Kallie about it in the morning.”
• “We’ll make plans to head out in the morning.”
• “I’ll think about it.” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “I think you know the answer to that.”
• “Sandwiched between two women? Yeah.”

If Kallie’s Anxiety is 2 or greater:

Choice

• “Check on her.” T Kallie +1 (Trust)
• “Leave her alone.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Doesn’t matter. I can’t taste anything right now.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety) F Kallie -1 (Friend)
• “I’m sure it’ll be great.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)

Once the girls start to enjoy the amenities of the fitness center: A Kallie -1 (Anxiety) A Laura -1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Go ahead and use the showers.” If Kallie’s Desire is 2 or more: D Kallie +1 (Desire) — At the end of this scene: D Laura +1 (Desire) D Kallie +1 (Desire) A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)
• “Give them their privacy.”

Choice

• “Just bugs you to do that?” T Kallie +1 (Trust)
• “Don’t mention it.”

Choice

• “No problem.”
• “You’d prefer Andrew were here, though.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety) D Kallie -1 (Desire)

Choice

• “We just grew apart.” T Kallie +1 (Trust)
• “Maybe I just wasn’t a good husband.” T Kallie +1 (Trust)
• “She’d already moved on.”
• “I’d rather not.”

Choice

• “Give Laura her space.”
• “Place a hand on her back.” F Laura +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “Okay. I will.” F Laura -1 (Friend)
• “Or, you could talk to me.”

Choice

• “I like to keep my ladies looking fine.” D Laura +1 (Desire)
• “Time was of the essence.”

Choice

• “Reason with her.”
• “Be stern about this.” F Kallie -1 (Friend)

On the way out the door: A Laura +1 (Anxiety)

Later in the following scene: A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “It’s okay. I’m here.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)
• “Let me see if I can scare it off.”

Later on, if Laura’s Friend stat is three or more and Desire is one or more:

Choice

• “Pull away.”
• “Keep going.” L Laura +1 (Love) D Laura -1 (Desire)

Choice

• “I believe you guys.” A Kallie -1 (Anxiety)
• “And you don’t?”

Choice

• “Talk to her about it.” A Laura -1 (Anxiety)
• “Maybe not.”

Choice

• “Can’t really see that far, though.”
• “We could try to head there.”

Choice

• “You want to sit around and watch?” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)
• “Hanging here all day may not be healthy.” T Laura +1 (Trust)

Choice

• “Say something.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)
• “Don’t say anything.”

Choice

• “You can stay here if you want.” F Kallie -1 (Friend)
• “I can try to move the body.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Not it.”
• “Let her say something.”

At night in the fitness center, if Kallie’s Friendship is seven or greater:

Choice

• “Consider it payment for the meals.”
• “To hug someone so adorable?” D Kallie +1 (Desire)

Choice

• “I do.”
• “You won’t get worse.” T Laura +1 (Trust)

If you had sex with Laura earlier or her Friendship is four or greater or her Desire is two or greater:

Choice

• “That sounds like a talk you two should have.” F Laura -1 (Friend) D Laura -1 (Desire)
• “He’s an idiot, then.” F Laura +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “Just listen.” This option will end the evening.
• “You’re right to feel this way.”

Choice

• “Keep quiet.”
• “Talk her up.” F Laura +1 (Friend) D Laura +1 (Desire)

Choice

• “Lean in.” L Laura +1 (Love)
• “Back away.”

The following morning: A Laura +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Other things came up.” T Laura -1 (Trust)
• “I was distracted.” (If you had sex the previous night.)
• “I didn’t want to get your hopes up.” T Laura +1 (Trust)

Choice

• “It’s going to be fine.”
• “You’re being brave.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “It’s nothing. Let’s go.” T Kallie -1 (Trust)
• “I think it’s nothing. I’ll catch up with you in a second.”
• “There’s a trail of blood on the ground.” T Kallie +1 (Trust) A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

In the restaurant: A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Tell her it’s okay.”
• “Tell her you’re proud of her.” T Kallie +1 (Trust)
• “Look to see where the creature is.”

At night, if Kallie’s Friendship is seven or greater:

Choice

• “Get out of there.”
• “Stay a little longer.” If her Desire is three or greater: D Kallie +1 (Desire) F Kallie +1 (Friend) A Kallie -1 (Anxiety)

When Laura takes you to the showers: D Laura +1 (Desire)

If you’ve slept with Laura in either of the two previous chapters:

Choice

• “Let me come out.”
• “Give me a little longer.” L Laura +1 (Love) D Laura -1 (Desire)

When Laura and Kallie are in the SUV: A Kallie -1 (Anxiety) A Laura -1 (Anxiety)

If Kallie’s Friend stat is 8 or higher:

Choice

• “Oh, I’m fine. Don’t worry.” T Kallie -1 (Trust)
• “I got lucky it wasn’t worse.” T Kallie +1 (Trust)

Choice

• “I’d like to get more supplies.” F Kallie -1 (Friend) F Laura -1 (Friend)
• “Sooner the better.”

Choice

• “Say “Good Morning”.” If Kallie’s Trust is 5 or higher: D Kallie +1 (Desire) — Else: F Kallie -1 (Friend)
• “Hold on a second.”
• “Slip out now.”

During the trip you will gain: A Kallie +2 (Anxiety) A Laura +2 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Are you sure? It’s heavy.” F Kallie -1 (Friend)
• “Sure thing.”

During the sequence where you help Kallie in the showers, the scene will differ based on whether Kallie’s Friend stat is 7+ / Trust is 6+. If her Friend stat is 9 or higher, you will get:

Choice

• “It wasn’t too bad when I brought you in here.”
• “I’m sure it’s cute as ever.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “Use your mother voice.” F Laura -1 (Friend)
• “You’ll do better than I will.”

Choice

• “We got lucky once.” F Laura +1 (Friend)
• “I wouldn’t count on it.”

Choice

• “Should we be worried?” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)
• “We’ll try with her later.”

If Kallie’s Friend stat is 10 or greater:

Choice

• “There are some cute outfits in it.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)
• “We could use any supplies we have.”

Choice

• “Best get back now.”
• “Maybe a little.” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)

As you meet Shelley for the first time: A Shelley +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “And after that?” A Shelley +1 (Anxiety)
• “Say nothing.”

Choice

• “Let it go for now.”
• “Ask anyway.” A Shelley +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “She may be holding something back.”
• “Trauma fucks with your memory.”

Choice

• “A few days.” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)
• “Long enough for Kallie to recover.”

Choice

• “I don’t know.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)
• “I’ll be in and out quickly.”

Choice

• “Give it to her.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety) F Kallie +1 (Friend)
• “Don’t mention it.”

Choice

• “Weeks is more like it.”
• “Perception of time is a weird thing.”

Choice

• “Face it head-on.”
• “Try to play things off.” T Laura -1 (Trust)

Choice

• “Back off.”
• “Wait a minute…” F Laura -1 (Friend)

Choice

• “Just blowing off steam.”
• “Been a rough few days.” T Shelley +1 (Trust)

Choice

• “If you rip a fart, I’ll laugh.”
• “I promise.” T Kallie +1 (Trust) F Kallie +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “Yeah.”
• “More than that.”

Choice

• “Ask her.” A Shelley +1 (Anxiety)
• “Don’t.”

Choice

• “We have to convince her otherwise.”
• “That’s her choice to make.” T Laura -1 (Trust)

Choice

• “A little too much in your own head?”
• “A little hard on yourself?”

Choice

• “She doesn’t think I’m a monster still…”
• “A little too much for me.”
• “She and Kallie seem to work.”

Choice

• “Ah, you look good in it.” F Laura +1 (Friend)
• “You got a tight body.” D Laura +1 (Desire)

If you’ve slept with Laura in Chapter 5:

Choice

• “One more round, and have some fun with it.” L Laura +1 (Love) D Laura +1 (Desire)
• “Time to call it a night.”

Choice

• “You did the smart thing.” A Shelley -1 (Anxiety)
• “I can be scary to look at.” F Shelley +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “Nothing much. Just fog.”
• “No one there except a Burned One.” A Shelley +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “You don’t need to.” F Shelley +1 (Friend)
• “It’d be for the best.” A Shelley +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Ask about her.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)
• “Ask about Laura.”

Choice

• “Drop it.”
• “Say something.” F Laura -1 (Friend)

Choice

• “I don’t think you have to worry.” T Kallie +1 (Trust)
• “You’re pretty no matter what.” F Kallie +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “I should get up and go. Before this gets too awkward.” This choice ends the scene early.
• “I’m gonna be blunt here.” If Kallie’s Friend score is 13+ OR 10+ and her Desire is 6+, she’ll ask you to stay the night and you’ll get the next choice below. Otherwise, the scene ends early.

Choice

• “Stay the night.” L Kallie +1 (Love) D Kallie -1 (Desire)
• “Leave now.” D Kallie +1 (Desire)

In the showers the following day: D Shelley +1 (Desire)

Choice

• “Give her a free show.” F Shelley +1 (Friend) D Shelley +1 (Desire)
• “Turn away.”

Choice

• “Be kind.” T Laura +1 (Trust)
• “Be stern.” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “She could try to go outside again.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)
• “I doubt it.” A Kallie -1 (Anxiety)
• “Anything’s possible.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “We’ve not had the best luck.” Leads to a follow-up choice (below).
• “Better off than some people.”

If you picked “We’ve not had the best luck.” above:

Choice

• “Does that mean I need to rub you?” F Shelley +1 (Friend) D Shelley +1 (Desire)
• “Hopefully you are.” F Shelley +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “I can’t force you.”
• “I’ll try to convince you otherwise.” A Shelley +1 (Anxiety)
• “If I have to knock you out and take you with us…” F Shelley +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “Ask about her.” If you ask all the questions before selecting “I think that’s enough for today,” you will additionally get: F Shelley +1 (Friend) T Shelley +1 (Trust) F Shelley +1 (Friend)
• “Let it go for now.”

Choice

• “You weren’t there for a while.” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)
• “It’s okay.”

Choice

• “Like your outfit leaves anything to the imagination.” F Shelley +1 (Friend) D Shelley +1 (Desire)
• “I should get going.”

Choice

• “I don’t know.” Depending on whether or not you slept with Kallie in Chapter 6, you’ll get one of the following two options that both lead to sex: “I would’ve.” OR “Is that why you came with me?” → L Kallie +1 (Love) D Kallie -1 (Desire)

Choice

• “Get to Laura now.”
• “Look around.”

Choice

• “Take a peek around us.” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)
• “Focus on Laura.”

Choice

• “Say your peace.” (Friend −1) F – -1 (Friend)
• “Let her off easy.” (Friend +1) F – +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “She’s not suicidal.”
• “She’s better.”
• “It wasn’t your fault.” A Shelley -1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “You aren’t.”
• “We all lose ourselves once in a while.”
• “I hope not.” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Stay with Laura.” T Laura +1 (Trust)
• “Leave.”

Choice

• “I’m just used to it being us three.”
• “She’s a wildcard right now.” A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

If Shelley’s Friend stat is 6 or greater or her Desire is 3 or greater:

Choice

• “I don’t think so.”
• “I won’t say no.” L Shelley +1 (Love) D Shelley -1 (Desire)

Choice

• “Sure, we’ll go for a short while.”
• “Really? So soon?”
• “You need to take it easy.”

Choice

• “Tell her to stay out in the hall.”
• “Don’t.”

Laura will stay in the hall if you tell her or her Anxiety is 5 or greater. If she does go in: A Laura +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “We do.” T Laura +1 (Trust)
• “Do we?” T Laura -1 (Trust)

Choice

• “We lost track of time.” T Shelley -1 (Trust) T Kallie -1 (Trust)
• “We heard a crash from the next building.”

As a result of the conversation: A Shelley +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Are you okay?” F Laura +1 (Friend)
• “Let it go.”

Choice

• “All right. Just tired but wired.”
• “I’ve had my fill of death.”

Choice

• “I’m sure it was sexy.” Unlocks the option to view future girl-on-girl content.
• “Not my relationship, not my call.”

Choice

• “You’re going to have to manage yourself.”
• “We’ll have to be aware.” F Shelley +1 (Friend) T Shelley +1 (Trust)

If Shelley’s Trust is 2 or greater, or her Love is 1 or greater, or her Friend stat is 5 or greater:

Choice

• “We should get up and go.”
• “Wanna fool around?” L Shelley +1 (Love) D Shelley +1 (Desire)

Choice

• “It’s my turn.” F Laura -1 (Friend)
• “Not if we stay together.”

If Kallie’s Friend stat is 12 or greater or you’ve had sex with her, she and Shelley will flash John.

Choice

• “Yes, we are.”
• “Speaking of which…” F Laura +1 (Friend)

If Kallie and Shelley flashed John earlier:

Choice

• “No, no. It’s okay.” This choice sets a flag for a future scene and Achievement. F Kallie +1 (Friend) F Shelley +1 (Friend)
• “Don’t get me wrong…”

Choice

• “Lay into her.” A Shelley +1 (Anxiety)
• “Ease into this.” F Shelley +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “All of us will.”
• “Yes. I will.” T Shelley +1 (Trust)

If Shelley’s Friend stat is 4 or greater or her Desire is 3 or greater:

Choice

• “Okay, a little.” F Shelley +1 (Friend) D Shelley +1 (Desire)
• “Yeah, no.”

Choice

• “This isn’t a democracy.” F Laura -1 (Friend)
• “That’s fair.”

If you’ve had sex with Kallie before:

Choice

• “Hold her to warm her up.” L Kallie +1 (Love) D Kallie -1 (Desire)
• “Suggest it’s time to head back.”

Choice

• “Kill him now.”
• “Run away.”

Choice

• “Tell her what you saw.” T Laura +1 (Trust) A Laura +1 (Anxiety)
• “Don’t.”

The scene with Laura and Kallie will change depending on whether you gave Kallie her cellphone earlier. If you didn’t: A Kallie +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “She’ll have to be.”
• “I’ll keep an eye on her.” A Laura -1 (Anxiety)

If you’ve had sex with Laura twice before and either her Friend stat is 10 or greater or her Desire is 4 or greater:

Choice

• “Want to feel normal-ish again?” This will trigger a scene later on. L Laura +1 (Love)
• “Glad I could be of some help.”

Choice

• “Leave her alone for now.”
• “Check in with her.” A Kallie -1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “You want to stop by?” F Shelley +1 (Friend)
• “You’ll find new places and new memories.”

Once you step outside: A Kallie +1 (Anxiety) A Shelley +1 (Anxiety) A Laura +1 (Anxiety)

If Shelley’s Anxiety is 4 or greater:

Choice

• “Put a hand on her back.” A Shelley -1 (Anxiety)
• “Grab her butt.” A Shelley -1 (Anxiety) D Shelley +1 (Desire)

Once at the Student Center, you will be given a content warning and a choice:

Choice

• “Continue”
• “I wish to skip this and all future content.”

Choice

• “When you say “we” you mean “me”.” F Laura -1 (Friend)
• “No time like the present.”

If you’ve had sex with Shelley before or her Friend stat is 8 or greater or her Desire is 5 or greater:

Choice

• “Not now.” A Shelley +1 (Anxiety) F Shelley -1 (Friend) D Shelley +1 (Desire)
• “I could, even if this is ill-timed.” L Shelley +1 (Love) A Shelley -1 (Anxiety) D Shelley -1 (Desire)

Choice

• “They’ve not shown that kind of interest.” A Laura -1 (Anxiety)
• “Burned Ones aren’t the problem.”

If you’ve had sex with Kallie (either twice or during Chapter 8):

Choice

• “Say something.”
• “Keep it to yourself.” This choice is the first chance for you to lay down the groundwork in telling Laura you’re sleeping with Kallie.

If you’ve had sex with Kallie in Chapter 8 or her Friend stat is 12 or greater:

Choice

• “Yes, all of us.” A Kallie -1 (Anxiety) F Kallie +1 (Friend) D Kallie +1 (Desire)
• “Me.”

The opening scene will change if Laura already knows about the note mentioning the Witch earlier.

Choice

• “Ask about her and Keith.” F Laura +1 (Friend) A Laura +1 (Anxiety)
• “Best not to bring it up.”

As you’re about to leave: A Shelley +1 (Anxiety)

Choice

• “Be honest about it.” T Shelley -1 (Trust)
• “She’s just struggling with the fog.” T Shelley +1 (Trust)

If Kallie’s Anxiety is less than 5, she’ll help John during the fight on the second floor.

Choice

• “Joke about it.” A Kallie -1 (Anxiety)
• “Adrenaline’s got me on a high.”

Choice

• “Go in.” This choice will set a flag that has the chance to impact the story later.
• “Don’t.”

Choice

• “Joke about it.” A Laura -1 (Anxiety)
• “I didn’t, though.”

Choice

• “You really think Laura will let us leave you?”
• “You really think I’m going to leave you?” F Shelley +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “It will do you a world of good.”
• “You know you like showing off for me.” F Shelley -1 (Friend)
• “You don’t have to, if you don’t want to.”

When you find Kallie in the library, if her Friend stat is 12 or greater and you slept with her in Chapter 8, you’ll get the following two choices:

Choice

• “I just want to minimize the nightmares.”
• “I’ll try to be better.”

Choice

• “Stay and nap.” L Kallie +1 (Love) A Kallie -1 (Anxiety) D Kallie -1 (Desire)
• “Time to get up.” D Kallie +1 (Desire)

If Laura’s Trust is 3 or lower, she will go upstairs to investigate the body: A Laura +1 (Anxiety)

If Shelley’s Friend stat is 9 or greater, she will ask you to share the couch with her. You will get the following choice:

Choice

• “We all do.”
• “I do.” F Shelley +1 (Friend)

Choice

• “I saw something.” T Laura +1 (Trust) A Laura +1 (Anxiety)
• “It’s nothing.” T Laura -1 (Trust)
• “It was more than a piss.”

If you’ve slept with Kallie in Chapter 8 or 10:

Choice

• “With feelings.”
• “Just for the sake of it.”

Choice

• “This is not a group decision.” F Laura -1 (Friend)
• “Okay, sure.”

Once John and Laura enter the gym storeroom, the following conversation will vary depending on your earlier choices.

If you’ve recently had sex with both Kallie and Laura:

Choice

• “Let’s get to it, then.” L Laura +1 (Love) D Laura -1 (Desire)
• “Come clean with her.”

Either way, John tells Laura about sleeping with Kallie.

If you haven’t slept with Kallie, but slept with Laura in Chapter 9 or 3 times so far:

Choice

• “Let’s get to it, then.” L Laura +1 (Love) D Laura -1 (Desire)
• “What’s going on here? Laura?”

Either way, John ends the scene with Laura irritated with him about where they are emotionally.

If you haven’t slept with Laura, but have slept with Kallie in Chapter 8 or 10, John comes clean with Laura.

To determine Laura’s mood at the end of this scene:
Not sleeping with Laura or Kallie: 0
Sleeping with both, told her before sex — Laura Trust 6+: 1, Trust 5 or less: 2
Sleeping with both, told her after sex — Trust 6+ & told her earlier in Ch9: 1, didn’t tell her earlier: 2
Sleeping with both, told her after sex — Trust 5 or less & told her earlier in Ch9: 2, didn’t tell her earlier: 3
Only sleeping with Laura: 1

Choice

• “I’ll be fine.”
• “I understand but it has to be done.”

Choice

• “Not as many as I used to.” T Kallie -1 (Trust)
• “Only things you don’t really need to know about.” A Laura +1 (Anxiety)
• “Just the Colonel’s secret recipe.” T Kallie -1 (Trust)

At night, the person who cuddles up with John on the mat will be: if you didn’t argue with Laura — Laura; if you’ve had sex with Kallie in Chapter 8/10 — Kallie; if neither of the above — Shelley.